Cecilia Dart-Thornton Resident Scholar Profiles TOP SCHOLAR: James Cooper SCHOLARS:
Would you like to be a scholar and make five dollars per review?
Click here to submit a review!
Review Summaries
"An amnesiac awakens in a strange place, and becomes disfigured by a poisonous plant. The plot describes the protagonist's search for identity and history. A journey is undertaken, through a world filled with amazing, magical creatures. Along the way secrets are discovered, and a little romance is encountered. The descriptions of this "Otherworld" are poetic and beautiful, the imagery is stunning. I would recommend this book to anyone. I could not put it down. I truly believe it will become one of the world's great classics. Since reading this book I have followed its progress on the Internet and seen that it has been listed as one of the Top Ten Amazon.com books of 2001, and also the Top Ten Locus magazine recommended reading. Now it has been nominated for the world fantasy award and I think this is well-deserved. I am not the only one who thinks this as many of my friends have read it and love it as well."
James Cooper, Resident Cecilia Dart-Thornton Scholar
"Deformed mute person, initially thinks self male, turns out to be female, escapes third-rate imitation Ghormenghast on flying ship, having encountered a million or so unmemorable characters. Reader dies at this point having been asphyxiated by adjective/fake archaism overload, bored witless and consumed by Irish Nationalist outrage at flagrant appropriation of ancestral language.
Is there anyone else on the planet who thinks this "dazzling" debut is hideously overwritten drivel in dire need of an editor?"
Suzycat, Resident Cecilia Dart-Thornton Scholar
"
Warner, May 2001, 24.95, 437 pp.
ISBN: 0446528323
In Isse Tower on Erith, the cretin's visage is so disfigured from poisonous plants that none of the lowest will have anything to do with it. With no memory beyond its' recent arrival and unable to speak, the creature becomes a drone doing whatever tasks are required, but quickly learns about windships and magic. However, drudgery seems pleasant when Mortier the Master Swordsman makes the urchin his servant.
Needing to escape from Mortier's abuse, the mute serendipitously hitches a ride on a windship, but is caught stowing away. The youth escapes and is rescued by the treasure seeking Sianadh. He provides her with the name Imrhien and teaches her how to communicate using sign language. Her adventures are just beginning (in this book and hopefully in future novels).
THE ILL-MADE MUTE is an entertaining fantasy work that has tons of action but at times feel more like a string of vignettes. The story line never slows down and the weird world of Erith seems genuine even with flying horses and the non-human wights. Imrhien is a strong individual who will garner much empathy yet remain an enigma as Cecilia Dart-Thornton never explains why much of the realm want her dead nor how she became mute and amnesiac (probably a future sequel). Still, this is a solid fantasy epic and genre fans will want to join Imrhien's trek across her planet.
Harriet Klausner
"
Harriet Klausner, Resident Cecilia Dart-Thornton Scholar
Click above for the new Obama Girl Parody video!
Overall Review
Our unique search engine breaks down books and movies into
dozens of literary elements, all of which are searchable.
Ratings are on a 1-10 scale (Low to High)
Plot
FANTASY or SCIENCE FICTION?
- fantasy world/fantasy past
Coming of age
Yes
Youngster becomes
- an adult (general)
Inner Struggle
Yes
Plotlet:
- fighting a personal illness/handicap
Is this an adult or child's book?
- Adult or Young Adult Book
Cultural problems, alien culture
Yes
Culture clash-
- one human from different culture of other humans
Main Character
Identity:
- Female
Sense of humor
- Mostly serious with occasional humor
Intelligence
- Smarter than most other characters
Physique
- average physique
Main Adversary
Intelligence
- Average intelligence
Physique
- average physique
Setting
Earth setting:
- during "Tolkien" (fairytime) times
A substantial portion of this book takes place on a non-Earth planetary body:
- humans in a primitive/fantasy society
Takes place on Earth?
Yes
Planet outside solar system?
Yes
Style
Person?
- mostly 3rd
How much dialogue?
- roughly even amounts of descript and dialog
TOP SCHOLAR: