science fiction

Talk directly to Starbuck Commander Adama

Trivia (click here): Who is the cylon that shoots adama?

Help rescue Starbuck from slavery! (click here)
TV-Commentary - Battlestar Galactica
Critical analysis of The Gun on Ice Planet Zero
The Gun on Ice Planet Zero was a great episode (if a little drawn out, a common problem with two parters). But there were some real plot problems with the episode that can't be ignored.

1) The Galactica was being driven into this gun, right? And the gun was on a planet, right? And planets ROTATE, right? Why not simply wait for the gun to rotate away from them and then run by during that time?

2) The gun was powerful but fired very, very slowly. Why not send a dozen vipers to attack it? By the time it fired back, it could only take a handful of them out.

3) Dr. Ravishol shooed the colonials away at the end, assuring him he could protect his clones from the returning Cylons. How? With what? If he had such a powerful weapon in reserve, how come the Cylons weren't using it, and why couldn't he give it to the fleet?

4) Was there no one else in the fleet who knew how to plant explosives except for convicts on the prison barge?


Click here to post a message




       EMS Vocoder 5000 posts on 5/2/2007 5:59:21 AM

That two-part episode was just on Ion. Aaah, to once again hear the sounds of the EMS Vocoder 5000 and a ring-modulator to boot.


       The commentator rand posts on 12/22/2005 1:09:34 AM

i believe the ice planet was really a moon, and i don't think moons rotate on their axis, of course i could be wrong. but if the moon or planet did or didn't rotate, why didn't the fleet just pass the planet from the other side? i also find it hard to believe that the galactica couldn't take the pulsar out with its own weapondry. those solium missiles packed quite a wallop. take care.


       The commentator Bang Bang posts on 12/21/2005 6:53:42 PM

With three Cylon base ships dogging the Galactica, maybe the Colonial Fleet didn't have enough time to wait for the planet to rotate and take the gun out of range. After all, Venus orbits the sun every 224 days, but it takes almost a year for it to rotate on its axis--thus, its "day" is longer than its "year." When Baltar kept attacking the battlestar to force it to keep on going, I wish they would've shown more of guys like Jolly, Greenbean, and so on, instead of just showing the stock footage of Vipers vs. Raiders. This would've given some of the secondary characters in the series more of a chance to shine. (I wish they would've shown Brie--from "Lost Planet of the Gods"--in this episode, during the Cylon attacks! After all, she became a Viper pilot, and she was certainly easy on the eyes!! Maybe they could've shown her walking around in her flight-suit underwear again!!) I always wondered what happened to Commander Croft at the end of the episode. He had been a convict on the prison barge, but presumably earned his freedom after blowing up the gun. He was in the military before; I thought they might show him in a future episode, perhaps piloting a Viper, but they never did. You'd think the Galactica could use all the pilots they could get their hands on.


       The commentator rand posts on 8/31/2005 10:50:59 PM

actually, the original galactica is the greatest sci-fi epic of all time, unlike that new piece of felgercarb on the sci-fi channel. let's see if anyone knows who katie sackoff and jamie bamber are thirty years from now.


       Just a Guy posts on 4/8/2005 3:14:10 PM

I disagree Killer...I think it should have been called "Hunky and Dory in the Land of Food."


       The commentator killer12382 posts on 4/7/2005 10:21:34 PM

One of the main problems with Battlestar Bonanza was some of the disjointed plots that the writers shot out. The Guns of Navarone in Space is what it should have been called.


       The commentator Tony Jnr posts on 4/4/2005 11:46:35 AM

What great stuff! Just finished watching galactica and ive gotta say after a lot of people putting it down i really enjoyed it - right from the mini-series to the end of the 1st series with a shock ending to match! Yes i know it looks cheap but with universal giving them another 20 episodes for a second season they can put more in and shows why star trek has fallen. I hope they can continue this as i think they're on a roll with this one! C Ya!


       Just a Guy posts on 4/2/2005 6:27:19 PM

I agree with Kent's post. In fact, I think there should be an absence of dialogue from TV and film altogether. Let's go back to the silent film age...when they really knew how to make movies.


       The commentator Kent posts supporting argument on 4/2/2005 3:08:30 PM

Very true. When attempts are made to incorporate expositional dialogue into the show or film itself (see Star Wars Ep. I & II), the results are usually disastrous. And disastrously boring.


       Insightful Vhela Psylocin posts on 4/1/2005 11:30:23 PM

Those really interested in BG would be well advised to read the books, available at almost any second hand bookstore. they give a lot of background information that gives weight to what we saw on TV. Remember, TV is primarily a visual, action oriented medium, so there is nota lot of emphasis on exposition...


       The Rubicon posts on 1/16/2005 5:39:50 AM

Well if we started putting facts into a fictious sci fi show then You'll not be able to suspend disbelief. You should just sit back, and enjoy it. Then you'll have a good time. As for the gun, note... not all planets rotate, or rotate so slowly it takes more than a year for venus to turn around once. the moon always has the same side facing earth. Ergo why do you assume this most likely captured ice planet on the edge of a paticular solar system, so. Its from 1978, they were all on acid back then.


Click here to post a message


Other Recent Battlestar Galactica Discussions

Was Battlestar Galactica politically conservative? 11/1/2009 9:51:45 AM

Why were the Cylons so slow and thinking impaired? 10/31/2009 8:36:52 PM

What's with the ladders in Cylon base ships? 7/8/2008 5:43:06 PM

Do Vipers fly past the speed of light? 6/26/2008 1:27:52 AM

Why did Starbuck choose the prostitute over the keyboard lady? 10/28/2007 8:58:35 PM

Why did they always shine that light in Baltar's face? 8/9/2007 5:27:49 AM

All the characters are Cylons1 6/7/2007 9:28:11 PM

How lame was the Battlestar Galactica remake? 5/2/2007 5:45:24 PM

Why was the show canceled? 5/2/2007 7:27:23 AM

Was anyone watching this show to see Boxey? 5/2/2007 6:25:14 AM

The worst episode of Battlestar Galactica 5/2/2007 6:21:33 AM

The Battlestar Galactica Remake has no robots! 5/2/2007 6:03:28 AM

Critical analysis of The Gun on Ice Planet Zero 5/2/2007 5:59:21 AM

The very best episode of Battlestar Galactica 5/2/2007 5:48:40 AM

Why did they kill off Starbuck? 4/8/2007 4:52:10 PM

Was Battlestar Galactica a rip-off of Star Wars? 3/16/2007 2:35:09 PM

Spoilers - Cylon Number 6 is going to kill Admiral Cain! 3/16/2007 12:55:50 PM

Is Number 6's crotch nuke proof? 12/21/2006 8:03:52 AM

Doesn't Starbuck look like Dick Cheney's Lesbian Daughter? 12/19/2006 12:38:31 PM

If Apollo gets Starbuck Pregnant, will they name it Boomer? 12/7/2006 1:37:43 PM

Why do Cylons wear skirts? 12/6/2006 12:23:12 AM

A Cylon baseship full of nude Boomers? 11/28/2006 12:58:32 PM

How did Colonial Warriors pilot their vipers if they looked down at targeting scanners? 11/6/2006 11:34:26 PM

Gold v. Silver Cylons 10/20/2006 9:52:02 PM

Why are the cylons so sex crazed? 10/6/2006 12:39:08 AM

Where are the Arab and American Indian Cylons? 10/3/2006 10:40:13 AM

Which character on the new Galactica has the worst face? 7/20/2006 10:02:52 PM

How come the Cylons couldn't track such a slow moving fleet? 4/30/2006 10:10:34 PM

Starbuck and Boomer are girls in the new Galactica miniseries! 3/24/2006 1:12:12 AM

Where did the Battlestar Galactica get fuel and vipers from? 3/23/2006 9:06:40 PM

Plotlines of new Battlestar Galactica episodes (spoilers) 3/16/2006 9:10:07 PM

The Return of Starbuck - What was that all about? 3/13/2006 2:05:28 PM

If Edward James Olmos is Adama, why can't Jennifer Lopez play Athena? 3/11/2006 10:39:20 PM

What will the Cylons do with Starbuck's eggs? 3/10/2006 2:32:04 AM

Jolly - too fat to fly a Viper? 3/5/2006 11:53:21 PM

Ensign Ro (Michelle Forbes) plays Admiral Cain! 2/2/2006 2:26:03 AM

What's with the Imperious Leader's afro? 12/27/2005 10:37:10 PM

What's with the King Tut helmets on Battlestar Galactica? 12/19/2005 11:37:15 PM

Should Senor Adama have laid off the tacos? 12/17/2005 11:37:05 PM

Why didn't they put doors on the Battlestar Galactica hanger bays? 12/8/2005 10:30:14 PM

Wasn't Baltar killed in the original movie? 12/6/2005 10:24:18 PM

Who was a better girlfriend, Sirena or Sheba? 8/26/2005 11:01:38 PM


Note: the views expressed here are only those of the posters.
Try our new Star Wars & Star Trek puzzle pictures! Click here

Advertise with us
Feedback
Star Wars Revenge of the Sith plot spoilers
Hobbits
The politics game
The lawyer game

3 Book search options!
1) Simple lookup
(title or author)

or
2) Detailed book search
(click here)
or

3) One-click plot searches! Simply click on a plot below!

Animal Story

Clones

Coming of age

Cultural problems, alien culture

Explore/1st contact/ enviro story

Family relations

GIANT monster(s)

Horror story?

Inner Struggle

Lifeform altered?

Mental/magical powers focus

Parody

Political power play

Religious overtones?

Repressive society story

Robots, Computers, VR

Romance

Spying & Investigations

Tech./$$$/Info hunt

Time Travel story?

Training/Apprent.

War or Invasion


Games:
Trivia Masters!

Rescue your favorite
scifi characters from
slavery!


Talk to your favorite
scifi characters!


Eating New Yorkers
Computer Game


Pomeranians

Most recent TV & Movie discussions:

Charmed: Is Piper really a Halliwell? 11/13/2009 11:30:45 AM

Lord of the Rings: Why would Aragorn choose pig lips Arwen Evenstar over Eowyn? 11/12/2009 6:40:39 PM

Xena: 37 reasons why Xena and Gabrielle are... you know.... 11/12/2009 7:23:13 AM

A Boy and His Dog: A Boy and His Dog 11/11/2009 11:48:16 PM

Battlestar Galactica: Was Battlestar Galactica politically conservative? 11/1/2009 9:51:45 AM

Battlestar Galactica: Why were the Cylons so slow and thinking impaired? 10/31/2009 8:36:52 PM

Blade Runner: Blade Runner 10/22/2009 2:43:11 AM

Star Trek Enterprise: Jolene Blalock on T'Pol and Star Trek Enterprise 10/19/2009 2:48:46 PM

Charmed: If Piper Halliwell gets pregnant, can Leo give her an abortion? 10/3/2009 12:29:33 PM

Star Wars: Why did stormtroopers wear armor that didn't work against blasters? 9/30/2009 9:48:47 PM


Newest slaves:
Cleavage Archer 9:20:38 AM
Akemi 9:20:00 AM
Timothy Dalton Bond 9:06:11 AM
Dr. Good Head 9:05:17 AM
Mrs. Robinson Mark II 9:03:28 AM
Slutty Russian Spy 8:56:38 AM
Oprah Winfrey 7:10:00 AM
Diana 7:05:47 AM
Indiana Jones (Harrison Ford) 7:05:12 AM
Darth Vader 6:52:55 AM
All slaves
(click here)


Celebrity interviews:
President George W. Bush 6:32:00 PM
Jan-Michael Vincent 2:16:51 PM
Captain Kathryn Janeway 3:47:46 PM
Jack ONeill (Richard Dean Anderson) 1:39:22 PM
Jennifer Aniston (Friends) 5:01:07 PM
All celebrities
(click here)